PunkTorah

Independent Jewish Spirituality Online

  • Convert to Judaism
  • Online Rabbinical Program
  • Donate

Neil deGrasse Tyson Made Me A Better Theologian

April 13, 2012 by Patrick Beaulier

I know, I know. Neil deGrasse Tyson is agnostic. But that doesn’t mean that man isn’t a believer at the same time.

My final assignment for rabbinical school is a thesis where I have to discuss my personal theological understanding of Judaism in the context of the Jewish future, and to use text to defend it. I must also include in the paper any kind of texts that contradict my theology and find ways to deal with those “difficult passages”. While I have a while before I get to this (one must crawl before running), I have to admit that I am terrified by writing this. There are some incredibly thorny passages in the Torah. How does a progressive Jew defend slaying Amelekites, stoning gay men, divorcing the spouses of interfaith marriages, and all the other troubling texts? It’s easy if you believe in an unquestionable Torah mi’Sinai that gives you the ultimate “out” of, “the Bible says it, I believe it, that settles it”. Problem is, if you’re the type to wrestle with text, no matter what you believe about the origin of our holy texts, you still have to figure out how to deal with all the fundamentalist sounding stuff that your modern sensibilities can’t stand.

Really good Jewish thinkers are willing to ask tough questions, to deviate from conventional thinking when things just don’t add up, and to willingly throw away any of their ideas that don’t hold up. I think the same must be true for scientists, which is why I often watch science programs on Netflix when I find myself unable to deal with religion. Surprisingly, Carl Sagan, Neil deGrasse Tyson and others don’t compel me away from the Divine, but rather, help me to more fully connect with the nature of the Universe, which I understand to be one of several projects that God has undertaken.

The video below really spells it out for me.

While Mr. Tyson and I probably disagree on the conclusion, what we can agree on is the spectacular nature of life: that we are made of all the same things that the universe is made up of, and that this is pretty cool. I know that “pretty cool” is an amateur, flippant way of describing the existence of reality, but you get my drift.

For me, this unity of all things is the seat of God. I find in the Shema the blessing of God’s oneness as a true-ism of all reality: that God is one, that the universe and everything in it is one, and that we are one with all of these elements at the same time. God, heaven, the past, present and future are all within us and at the same time, outside of us.

As a self-professed “serial monogamist”, I can speak with a certain level of authority that no relationship is perfect and that while we hope that everything we do is to the benefit of our partner, or is at least keeping them in mind, often times we just act on our own self-interest. In an interview, Tyson said that “every account of a higher power that I’ve seen described, of all religions that I’ve seen, include many statements with regard to the benevolence of that power. When I look at the universe and all the ways the universe wants to kill us, I find it hard to reconcile that with statements of beneficence.” 

When we look at the way a single change in the coming together of our universe could have completely prevented humanity from ever existing, it gives us an amazing pause to think: perhaps the world is made with love in mind. As Einstein said, “God doesn’t play dice with the world.” At the same time, I can see where Tyson is coming from. The world is amoral; children are born with genetic diseases that take their lives before they have the opportunity to live, earthquakes and other natural phenomena sweep people off to eternity regardless of how holy or evil they are, and by most trustworthy accounts, the Earth will be destroyed by the sun, no matter how much faith we put into God to prevent that from happening.

Perhaps though, we are trying to fit a square God into a round hole. Perhaps God is not benevolent or the destroyer: God just is. Just as our relationships with those we love are never simple, perhaps God, who I have always viewed as the ultimate in complicated, complex issues, cannot be made into a boiler plate one-liner.

Our faith tradition gives us two ways to take refuge under God’s shechinah in spite of the terrible amount of mental noise that the why-God-why type questions cause us. As I mentioned before, the Shema’s declaration of oneness of God is a no-brainer. God is one, and from Tyson we learn that everything in the universe is one. Oneness disguised as diversity and chaos seems to be God’s operating philosophy.

The second point comes from liturgy. When we pray the Amidah, we pray “blessed are you…God of Abraham, God of Isaac, God of Jacob”. Martin Buber in The Ten Rungs, a collection of Chasidic philosophy, explained that the reason we say “God of” before each name, is that God was revealed to each of these individuals, and to all of the prophets, in different ways and at different times. God is not a singular experience, but rather, an experience that each generation is tasked with in its own way. Perhaps science is just another of God’s prophecies.

From that place, I am able to sit with my non-theistic friends and know that when we talk about the stars in the sky, the birth of a child, or any other life affirming moment, the “ooh, ahh” noises we make reflect a shared experience of the transcendental.

Filed Under: Community Member Blogs Tagged With: atheists, convert to judaism, darshan yeshiva, jewish agnostic, jewish atheism, jewish atheist, jewish theology, Neil deGrasse Tyson, patrick "aleph" beaulier, patrick aleph, punktorah, rabbi beaulier, rabbi patrick aleph beaulier, rabbinical school, science and god, science and judaism, science and religion, science and theology

Dafna Steinberg: Spirituality, Ritual & Religion

March 27, 2012 by Patrick Beaulier

httpv://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6LQS7G_o45Y

Dafna Steinberg talks about her personal feelings on superstition, spirituality & who and what God is to her.

Filmed at Washington, DC JCC. Visit us at www.theg-dproject.org

Filed Under: Podcasts & Videos, The G-d Project Videos Tagged With: "DC JCC", atheism, dafna steinberg, jewish atheism, punktorah, the g-d project, the god project

Tucker Lieberman: God Is Not Involved In Creation Or Ethics

March 11, 2012 by Patrick Beaulier

Submitted via YouTube, Tucker Lieberman of Boston doesn’t believe that God is involved in the creation of the universe, morality, or any of these traditional ideas. “Two big reasons why I don’t believe in the classical definition of God: it doesn’t help us understand how the world got here, and it doesn’t help us make moral decisions.” Submit your own G-d Project video by clicking here.

Visit us at www.theg-dproject.org

Filed Under: Podcasts & Videos, The G-d Project Videos Tagged With: definition of god, god and ethics, god and morality, humanistic judaism, Jewish, jewish atheism, jewish boston, jewish god, Judaism, limmud, the g-d project, the god project, tucker lieberman

Dafna Steinberg: Does Being Religious Make You Jewish?

January 16, 2012 by Patrick Beaulier

httpv://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SEf8ETY8d4g

Dafna Steinberg talks about a college Chabad table encounter. Does being religious make you a good Jew?

Filmed at Washington, DC JCC. Visit us at www.theg-dproject.org

Filed Under: The G-d Project Videos Tagged With: Chabad, convert to judaism, convert to judaism online, dafna steinberg, darshan yeshiva, frum, frum jews, jewish atheism, online conversion, patrick "aleph" beaulier, patrick aleph, punktorah, rabbi beaulier, rabbi patrick aleph beaulier, the g-d project, the god project

Joshua Kaplan’s Cultural Jewish Background

September 12, 2011 by Patrick Beaulier

httpv://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cSW2ySJ5WPg

Is there room for G-d in a scientific family? The G-d Project is the world’s first social media platform dedicated to Jewish spirituality. We bring God back to the conversation. www.theg-dproject.org.

Filed Under: Podcasts & Videos, The G-d Project Videos Tagged With: convert to judaism, convert to judaism online, darshan yeshiva, jewish atheism, jewish family, jewish scientists, Joshua Kaplan, long beach hillel, patrick "aleph" beaulier, patrick aleph, punk torah, punktorah, rabbi beaulier, rabbi patrick aleph beaulier, the g-d project, the g-d project jewish, the god project, the god project jewish

PunkTorah Inc.
PO Box 1641
Midlothian, VA 23113

questions@punktorah.org
YouTube
Facebook

Read our DMCA notice

Search the PunkTorah Blog Archive

What We Do

Pluralistic Rabbinical Seminary: Online Rabbinical Program

Now Hiring: Rabbis, Educators & Creatives

Become a Jewish Spiritual Leader

  • Jewish Text (Torah/Haftarah/Talmud)
  • Judaism & Belief
  • The G-d Project Videos
  • Podcasts & Videos
  • NewKosher (Recipes)
  • Converting To Judaism
  • LGBTQ & Women
  • Shabbat & Holidays

Copyright PunkTorah Inc.© 2023